Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads in Forex Trading

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads in Forex Trading

The spread is the difference between the bid and ask prices of a security, asset or a currency pair. You may also call the spread the bid-ask price difference. Usually, the spread is the compensation that the broker gets from executing the orders of the trader.

Two types of spreads exist in the forex market. These are known as:

  • A) Fixed spreads
  • B) Variable spreads

The type of spread that you will encounter will depend on the business model of your broker, and how the broker collects the compensations for offering you trading services. In some of our earlier articles on this site, we took time to describe the types of brokerage models available in the forex market. These two brokerage models are the non-dealing desk brokerages and the dealing desk brokerages.

Non-dealing desk brokerages tend to offer variable (raw/floating) spreads in the market, while the dealing desk brokers (market makers) offer fixed spreads. But what are fixed and variable spreads?

Let us compare fixed spreads and variable spreads and see if we can come up with some similarities and differences. The table below summarizes the conditions that come with each type of spread.

Fixed spread vs Variable spread

Each metric will be examined in detail.

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads: Bid-Ask Range

When the spreads on an asset are fixed, it simply means that the difference between the bid and ask prices of that asset stay the same with the passage of time, no matter the market circumstances. Therefore, if the spread on the EURUSD is 2 pips, it will continue to remain at 2 pips no matter the prevailing market conditions.

On the contrary, when spreads are said to be variable or floating, it means that the difference between the bid and ask prices on a particular asset or security fluctuates with time, depending on the market circumstances. So if the spread at 7am on Tuesday on the EURUSD is 2 pips, the spread may narrow to 1.2 pips at 12 noon, or it may even widen at 7.02 am on the same day to 10 pips. Variable spreads tend to widen during major economic news releases, and narrow or contract when there is low liquidity.

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads: Brokerage Models

There is a reason why market makers offer fixed spreads. They are essentially matching their clients orders to positions they have already assumed “in-house” via their dealing desk departments. They are therefore able to offer controlled pricing to their clients, which allows them to keep spreads fixed.

Non-dealing desk brokers have no control over their clients’ trades except in the aspect of order transmission. At the level of the interbank market or the prime brokers, there are usually many liquidity providers that offer different spreads for any single asset. The bid-ask range here is therefore subject to variation from market forces, volatility, etc. That’s why variable spreads are a feature with the non-dealing desk brokerages.

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads: Execution Costs

If you are subject to changing spreads which could widen during intense volatility, then it goes without saying that variable spreads lead to higher execution costs for the trader than fixed spreads.

Again, fixed spreads allow traders to count their cost before entering into trades. You know exactly what you are paying your broker even before you execute the trade. This is usually difficult with variable spreads, but because variable spread traders usually have deeper pockets, they are able to absorb the sudden spread changes better.

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads: Capital Requirements

Traders who use fixed spreads are typically small time traders whose trading capital is not more than $9,999. Very commonly, you will find that many of these traders do not even have up to $1000 to trade with. Such traders would never be able to handle variable spread scenarios.

In contrast, variable spread traders usually have deep pockets as their brokers usually insist on large minimum deposits that usually top $10,000. This capital ensures that the traders involved can many such spread changes without losing their shirts.

Fixed Spreads vs Variable Spreads: Effect on Trading Styles

Forex trading is characterized by different trading styles: scalpers, day traders, swing traders and position traders. The difference between these styles lies mainly in the duration of trades. Scalpers rarely stay in a trade for more than a few minutes. Day traders are in trades for a few hours and never exceeding one day. Swing traders are in trades for days to weeks, and position traders hold positions for months on end.

Fixed or variable spreads may not matter much to swing or position traders, but to scalpers and day traders, they mean the world in terms of profits or losses. Scalpers try to make a few pips at a time over many trades in order to earn a profit. For trades that are held for such a short time, the spread makes a lot of difference.

Let’s assume the scalper is trying to earn 10 pips on the EURUSD, with a fixed spread of 2 pips. This means that the scalper only needs to earn 12 pips to achieve the target. However, the game changes when variable spread brokers are used. Assuming the scalper wants to earn 10 pips and on execution finds that the spread has widened to 8 pips on the EURUSD: what happens? The scalper would then need to make 18 pips to achieve the profit target. Therefore, the decision to use fixed or variable spreads can impact the profitability of your trading styles or strategies very quickly.

So whether you choose to trade with fixed spreads or variable spreads, you should know what each style offers you so you can plan your trades accordingly.

Show Results